Home > Sudbury News

Woman who took baby had difficult life

This is Not an act that deserves to be looked at like it wasn't her fault. Batisse did what she did and no matter what the circumstances are in her past, should not have even...

Posted by: Anonymous User

Read All Comments

Article Tools

Nov 26, 2007

By:

BY LAUREL MYERS

The 29-year-old Kirkland Lake woman charged with abducting a baby from the Sudbury Regional Hospital earlier this month was released from police custody following a review of her bail hearing last week.

Defence attorney Berk Keaney took the opportunity of the review to more accurately portray the difficult life Brenda Batisse endured leading up to the abduction.

“The most significant factor to me is that this woman has been demonized in the public since this incident occurred because no one understood her personal circumstances,” he said. “Now there will be a different light on it and I expect a change in the public reaction.”

As Keaney described, Batisse’s life was one filled with sexual, emotional and physical abuse.

“At the age of 11, her step-father’s brother began sexually abusing her and it continued for the next six years,” Keaney said. “During these years, Brenda did not have or enjoy a caring or nurturing relationship with her mother and didn’t have the advantage of feeling her mother’s love.”

At 18, her mother died during the trial of Batisse's step-uncle. Batisse and her sister were bounced around between many relatives' homes.
 
Two years later, Batisse was diagnosed with Type 1 Diabetes and requires daily injections of insulin.

In 2003, her stepfather was diagnosed with cancer and died two years later.

Keaney also said Batisse had been in a nine-year relationship that showed indications of abuse.

At the age of 21, Batisse gave birth to her first daughter. At the age of 24, her second daughter was born.

In early October of this year, Batisse claimed to have given birth to a five-month old stillborn baby, following a physical beating in her hometown.

After being assessed by a forensic psychologist following the abduction, Batisse was found to be suffering from a major depressive disorder.

Batisse has written a letter of apology to the mother of the baby she abducted.

“My intentions were never to hurt anyone but just to make my family whole again,” she wrote. “I am not a bad person and would never hurt you or your sweet baby girl. My life has been quite cruel to me. I've had many losses and I just wanted to bring home a beautiful baby to my girls.”

Batisse will appear in court in the new year to determine her sentencing. An abduction charge carries a maximum 10-year sentence.

For more information on the bail hearing and the details of the abduction, see Wednesday's paper.

Bookmark and Share

Reader's Feedback

Editor’s Note:

NorthernLife.ca may contain content submitted by readers, usually in the form of article comments or postings to myNews. All reader comments and any opinions, advice, statements or other information contained in any messages posted or transmitted by any third party are the responsibility of the author of that message and not of NorthernLife.ca. The fact that a particular message is posted on or transmitted using this web site does not mean that NorthernLife.ca has endorsed that message in any way or verified the accuracy, completeness or usefulness of any message. We encourage visitors to NorthernLife.ca to report any objectionable content by using the "report abuse" link found in the comments section of this web site.

1 Comments

  • This is Not an act that deserves to be looked at like it wasn't her fault. Batisse did what she did and no matter what the circumstances are in her past, should not have even attempted doing so. She should have seeked help a long time ago for her issue but taking a baby out of a hospital is an outrage! If it were my baby being taken, I would not stop until the person responsible pays for what they have done. Now I know many people are going to reply to this comment and try to make pity all over the place, but so you know, we live in a corrupt society as it is. These kinds of articles only make people even angrier at what took place and how it's going to be solved. This case should be as open and shut as taking clothes out of my drawer every morning before work, and she should be punished to the full extents of the law. As for the hospital, I ridicule your ways of keeping tight security. I've spent nights in there with sick family and friends and while waiting walked around. There is a HUGE lack of security for any floor there, especially the nursery. Enough is enough! Time to beef up security so this doesn't happen again and to future kidnappers out there - GET HELP NOW BEFORE YOU GET PITY FROM THE COURTS FOR KIDNAPPING AN INFANT!