HomeColumns

Column: Liberals' red machine spewing smoke

By: Darren MacDonald - Sudbury Northern Life

 | Apr 02, 2014 - 12:54 PM |
Premier Kathleen Wynne's fumbling of the nomination process in Sudbury reflects her government's struggles with local issues as a whole. File photo.

Premier Kathleen Wynne's fumbling of the nomination process in Sudbury reflects her government's struggles with local issues as a whole. File photo.

Local resentment festers as Wynne fumbles the Sudbury file

The once mighty Liberal machine in Sudbury is sputtering, stalling and spitting out black smoke, even as the party careens toward an election it can no longer avoid.

Since the 2011 provincial vote, when Sudburians decided they were tired of Rick Bartolucci and his apparently annoying habit of bringing big money and influence to the riding, local Liberals have struggled to chart their future. And the tall foreheads in Toronto haven't made it easy.


When Bartolucci announced his retirement in January 2013, he left a strong campaign narrative for whoever succeeded him. Voters showed they wanted change, but it's not like the former cabinet minister scorched the Earth on his way out the door.

Cliffs Natural Resources was preparing to build its billion-dollar chromite refinery in Capreol; money-losing Ontario Northland was going to be sold; and, the Ontario Lottery and Gaming modernization plan was going to add significant revenue to the province – and to cities that wanted casinos.

Not that everyone loved the plan, but at least those elements of the Drummond Report offered a path toward balancing the books. Yes, there were tough choices, but governments willing to make tough choices used to get elected in Ontario.

But modern politics, more than ever before, is hyper focused on demographics and blocs and message. Voters are not individuals so much as we are demographics who will vote for parties who like what we like, hate what we hate. When Kathleen Wynne took over from Dalton McGuinty, she started unravelling policies that were killing the Liberals among certain demographics.

The OLG plan, for example, was killing them in rural Ontario, where ending the slots at racetracks program had a much bigger impact than, say, Toronto. So racetracks have been spared, sort of, and the OLG insists the casino plan is still moving forward, but really, it's dead. Cliffs has suspended all work in Ontario, even as the Liberals keep unveiling plans on how they plan to make decisions at some point in the future. The ONTC may not be sold, after all. And, I guess, chronic budget deficits are no longer a problem.

I'm not saying these policies were visionary, but at least someone was saying that we have to make tough decisions if we want a better future. Today, instead of blue books and red books, we have policy papers crafted on the fly to appease voting blocs.

Tim Hudak's Conservatives, for example, bill themselves as fiscal conservatives, even as they promise everyone everything and populate their website with white papers that resonate with no one.

The NDP and Andrea Horwath, ironically, say they will bring the government down if it raises taxes on middle-income earners. We know they want to spend a lot of money, and the Liberals are poaching their policy ideas, but who's going to pay for all of it? Don't worry, all three parties seem to be saying, we'll hold the line on taxes, balance the books and not cut any programs that you like. Trust us.

Which brings us to the battle to name a candidate in Sudbury. The riding association tried, for months and months, to get someone to run to replace Bartolucci. And when two attractive, if inexperienced, candidates finally stepped forward – engineer Elise Idnani and businessman Andrew Olivier – you would expect high fives all around.

But no. Just as Wynne's government fumbled the Sudbury file on the big issues, it appears they also want to micromanage the succession process to ensure it's a mess, as well.

I guess losing the refinery, casino revenue and any semblance of appearing to be fiscally responsible wasn't enough. Now they appear intent on either foisting someone on the local riding association, or waiting until the last minute before allowing local Liberals the privilege of electing their candidate.

The gas plant scandal won't go away. The Ring of Fire is frozen. Hydro rates are soaring. Municipalities are starved for funds. The province is bleeding money. And all of this is top of mind for voters just as the Liberals head into an election campaign.

All of which raises two questions: why would anyone want the nomination in Sudbury? And, if I'm the candidate, how do you sell voters on a premier who has been tone deaf – at best – when it comes to the Nickel City?
Darren MacDonald

Darren MacDonald

Staff Writer

@Darrenmacd

Reader's Feedback

NorthernLife.ca may contain content submitted by readers, usually in the form of article comments. All reader comments and any opinions, advice, statements or other information contained in any messages posted or transmitted by any third party are the responsibility of the author of that message and not of NorthernLife.ca. The fact that a particular message is posted on or transmitted using this web site does not mean that NorthernLife.ca has endorsed that message in any way or verified the accuracy, completeness or usefulness of any message. We encourage visitors to NorthernLife.ca to report any objectionable content by using the "report abuse" link found in the comments section of this web site. Comment Guidelines


comments powered by Disqus

Most Popular

Local Business Directory