A Mother's Story

Aidan Lumley's mother, Elaine, wants to prevent other young people from being killed needlessly.

Aidan Lumley's mother, Elaine, wants to prevent other young people from being killed needlessly.

May 12, 2006- 10:17 PM

By:

BY KEITH LACEY

Today, Mother's Day, will be filled with emptiness for Elaine Lumley.

ELAINE LUMLEY

This will be Lumley's first Mother's Day since her only child, Aidan, 20, was senselessly gunned down outside a Montreal nightclub almost six months ago.

Aidan was in Montreal to celebrate a friend's birthday and the end of first semester exams from Trent University in Peterborough. He was a third-year, straight A physics student who aspired to become a doctor. He was the grandson of Margaret, and the late Rev. Robert Lumley of Sudbury. The young man was buried next to his grandfather in the Anglican cemetery in Sudbury.

"Aidan was the love of my life," said a tear-filled Lumley in front of 100 friends and family members at a sombre, but uplifting memorial benefit concert she organized Monday in Toronto.

"I felt like I had to do something for Aidan...I had to put a face to this horrible crime."

The benefit was the launch of her national postcard campaign calling on Prime Minister Stephen Harper to put an end to the proliferation of handguns across this vast country, particularly in our three largest cities.

Lumley wants to make a profound impact with her postcard campaign.

Half of the first printing of 5,000 postcards show a recent picture of her handsome, six-foot-three son and a "no  handguns" symbol.  Aidan's name and the words "young, beautiful and DEAD" with the last word in large upper case red letters are printed on the card. The day he died Nov. 27, 2005 is inscribed across the bottom of each card. The other half of the first printing do not have "DEAD " on the bottom.

Aidan Lumley's mother, Elaine, wants to prevent other young people from being killed needlessly. She has started a postcard campaign she hopes will deliver a message to the prime minister about the need to ban handguns.

At the back of each postcard reads, "Aidan Lumley was a third-year university student.

Ontario swimming champion. Tall. Handsome. Funny. Aidan was shot in the back...in Montreal, Nov. 27, 2005. The murderers have never been caught, but they will. Please put an end to handguns on our Canadian streets."

Lumley wants to make a difference to honour her son's memory and try to prevent other young people from being killed needlessly.

"I'm outraged our sons and daughters continue being killed because of gun violence," said Lumley.

She will send postcards to any organization, individual or community leader in Canada that requests them. She plans to continue holding benefits and raising cash to continue the campaign.

"If we could send a couple hundred thousand of these postcards to Stephen Harper's office, I think we could make a difference," she said. "We're starting small, but I hope we'll get really strong reaction...Canadians everywhere are sick and tired of seeing our young people being killed senselessly."

Elaine Lumley was born and raised in Sudbury. Her father, a well-known Anglican minister, died two years ago. Lumley has worked in Toronto's vibrant theatre community for many years.

Aidan was born in Sudbury and spent his formative years here before moving to Toronto with his mother at a young age.  Aidan had many friends in Greater Sudbury as he spent most summers working here and sailing at the Sudbury Yacht Club.

A determined, vibrant and intelligent woman, Lumley said she had to do something after her son's death to try and make a difference.

She has been on national television numerous times in the past five months after stepping forward as an advocate against handguns.

She's met far too many other parents who have lost children to violence.

Lumley would like to meet Harper in person to plead her case.

"I'd love to meet him," she said. "I'd like to appeal to him not as a politician, but as a father...I don't want any other parent to have to go through what me and my family and Aidan's friends have been through."

Harper has advocated stiff minimum sentences for anyone who commits crimes involving handguns or illegally possessing them, and "that's a good start," said Lumley.

However, having Canadians demand a crackdown on illegal handguns, being brought across the border from the United States, is going to take a lot of political will and many millions of dollars, she said.

"The guns are here," she said. "I never, ever thought I'd be having to talk about this, but the guns are here and people are dying.

"It should make all of us furious. We should all be saying 'no more, no more'."

She admits she hasn't started any kind of healing process, but keeping busy with the postcard campaign and organizing events to honour Aidan have helped her immensely.

"When I watch television now and see another young person has been killed (because of handgun violence), it just breaks my heart all over again," she said. "I can feel my heart breaking into a million little pieces."

The Benefit for Aidan Lumley was held at Theatre Passe Muraille, near Bathurst St. and Queen St. E. Performers included Mutahdi and the World Drummers, Toronto singer-songwriter James Longo, Toronto band Johnny Ecstasy and folk performers Rodney Brown and Ian Tamblyn, who are both well-known to regular attendees of Northern Lights Festival Boreal, as both have performed numerous times over the years.

Max Kandler, 20, Aidan's best friend was master of ceremonies at the concert. Not a day goes by when he doesn't think about him.

"I know he still affects me everyday because he had such a positive outlook on life and cared so much about helping other people," he said. "He never acted like he was smarter than other people and used to pretend he didn't study or do homework. But then he'd show me his marks and he'd get an another A in physics. You don't do that unless you've got something going on upstairs."

Kandler has lived his entire life in Toronto and can't believe what's happening with young people and guns.

"And it's not just in places like Jane and Finch (a notorious neighbourhood )...People are going out to clubs with guns and they're not looking to protect themselves, but looking to cause trouble," he said.

"These people have a lack of purpose in life and something has to be done to keep them from getting access to these guns."

Toronto lawyer John Legge, a close family friend and Aidan's former Scouts leader, brought the audience to tears recalling Aidan's passion for life and helping others.

Aidan cared about the less fortunate and always wanted to make a difference, said Legge.
"He was the first to volunteer to help the homeless...the first to volunteer at his church...he was a decent, good kid."

Legge said he's attended funerals of former governor-generals, leading politicians, judges and many friends, but he has never witnessed the overwhelming emotion and huge numbers who showed up to say goodbye to a special young man.

Aidan had a "brilliant mind" and would have become a successful and influential physician, he said. "We have all been deprived because Aidan was senselessly and needlessly murdered," he said.

Legge said he hopes the person who shot Aidan twice from behind at point-blank range knows what kind of wonderful person he killed and prays he has the courage to turn himself in and get help.

"There was no fight, no provocation, no reason," he said. "It was most certainly a case of being in the wrong city at the wrong place at the wrong time."

Banning handguns and instituting stiff penalties has never been more important as too many families are having lives shattered by violent criminals with easy access to weapons of destruction.

If enough Canadians demand stiff sentences by the criminal justice system, and judges and police and government priorities are placed on banning handguns, the problem will not go away, but will be drastically reduced and will save young lives, said Legge.

"This has got to stop," said Legge.

Aidan's mother says her road to healing will ease when the man responsible for killing Aidan is arrested. The Montreal detective in charge has assured her they have a suspect, but are having difficulty finding him as witnesses have been less than co-operative.

If her son's killer was unable to access an illegal handgun, Aidan would still be alive and continuing a life filled with wonder, excitement, promise and potential, she said.


"This isn't happening just in Toronto or Montreal, but it could happen in Sudbury or any small town you want to name," she said. "We have to get these handguns off the streets now."

Anyone interested in donating to the Aidan Lumley Fund, can write Elaine Lumley at 557 Indian Rd., Toronto, M6P 2B9.

Read More: Home > Lifestyle

Reader's Feedback

Editor’s Note:

NorthernLife.ca may contain content submitted by readers, usually in the form of article comments. All reader comments and any opinions, advice, statements or other information contained in any messages posted or transmitted by any third party are the responsibility of the author of that message and not of NorthernLife.ca. The fact that a particular message is posted on or transmitted using this web site does not mean that NorthernLife.ca has endorsed that message in any way or verified the accuracy, completeness or usefulness of any message. We encourage visitors to NorthernLife.ca to report any objectionable content by using the "report abuse" link found in the comments section of this web site.

17 Comments

  • "The legal system protects the criminal, what are we going to do about it?"

    Support the Conservatives omnibus crime bill. Ask for capital punishment to be reinstated. Ask for life in jail to be that, never get out. Let me give you an example of what we can have here in Canada. In several US States if someone is involved in a criminal act where someone dies, regargless of the reason, regardless how, then everyone is charged with criminal murder, even if that person didnt pull the trigger. In the US you get life for that. This is what we need to have here. Deal with criminals in a manner they understand by dramatically increasing the risk/reward ratio for them. Up the risk big time. The past 30 years of liberal ideological pandering to the criminals, placing the blame off them and onto society had a very large part in your son's death. You should fight to end that. Wanna bet if the guy is found we find out he was parroled for another violent crime? The odds are in that favour.

    Thus, your frustration and fight is with the criminal element that has flourished under the socialist Liberals for 30 years. Not us legal and responsible firearms owners. We are easy targets for your anger, I can understand that. But the easy target isn't always the right target. Such is the case here.

  • "The legal system protects the criminal, what are we going to do about it?"

    Support the Conservatives omnibus crime bill. Ask for capital punishment to be reinstated. Ask for life in jail to be that, never get out. Let me give you an example of what we can have here in Canada. In several US States if someone is involved in a criminal act where someone dies, regargless of the reason, regardless how, then everyone is charged with criminal murder, even if that person didnt pull the trigger. In the US you get life for that. This is what we need to have here. Deal with criminals in a manner they understand by dramatically increasing the risk/reward ratio for them. Up the risk big time. The past 30 years of liberal ideological pandering to the criminals, placing the blame off them and onto society had a very large part in your son's death. You should fight to end that. Wanna bet if the guy is found we find out he was parroled for another violent crime? The odds are in that favour.

    Thus, your frustration and fight is with the criminal element that has flourished under the socialist Liberals for 30 years. Not us legal and responsible firearms owners. We are easy targets for your anger, I can understand that. But the easy target isn't always the right target. Such is the case here.

  • "Maybe if someone killed your child with a gun, you would feel different about your ridiculous theory on guns. For the record, GUNS DO KILL PEOPLE"

    First, let me state that I cannot fathom in any way what you have suffered, and continue to suffer at the loss, especially in this manner. It is easy to want to blame someone, usually those so easy to blame, lawful gun owners. How would I feel? The same way I would feel if a drunk driver killed one of my children. But I would not demand that all cars be taken off the road. Guns do not kill people any more than cars do. Someone has to pull the trigger. It was someone with an illegal pistol who murdered. Not any of us with long guns. Your aim is not us. It's the criminals on the street. If the 2 billion had been spent on police forces it is likely this murder would have been caught. The only possible justice I can offer is that murders like him not only live by the sword, but die by the sword. But please, do not force us legal and ligitimate firearms owners to suffer because of your loss. We are not to blame.

  • ohh the misguided drama laced with pathetic fallacy.

    She can deliver her tragic act to whom ever wishes to listen, the fact is still and always will be is that her voice will not change a thing.

    Lets clear the emotional baffles and instead focus where it will matter: crackdown on the criminals - crack down on the illegal weapons.

  • "I will stand up for my son I will not rest until the murderer and his friends are charged I will tell these fat, single minded idiots that guns do kill. What are you protecting yourself from the chips and dip on your coffee table. Have another beer you ignoramous Aidan lived a good life he tried to make a difference, you gun lovers are a blight on our society. Sleep with your hand gun I am sure it brings you comfort instead of living a good and fulfilling life. Aidans mom elaine"

    Ma'am I sympathize with you, your son didn't deserve this, no one does. Unfortunately your comments here will alienate firearms owners who would otherwise be with you.

    I own long guns, many of them. And I use marksmenship as a way of working through my PTSD. That's why I own them and I'm saddened that you seem to view us as fat rednecks.

    I hope you find closure some day, and I encourage you to look at our side, lawful owners who didn't murder anyone.

  • "I will stand up for my son I will not rest until the murderer and his friends are charged I will tell these fat, single minded idiots that guns do kill. What are you protecting yourself from the chips and dip on your coffee table. Have another beer you ignoramous Aidan lived a good life he tried to make a difference, you gun lovers are a blight on our society. Sleep with your hand gun I am sure it brings you comfort instead of living a good and fulfilling life. Aidans mom elaine"

    Ma'am I sympathize with you, your son didn't deserve this, no one does. Unfortunately your comments here will alienate firearms owners who would otherwise be with you.

    I own long guns, many of them. And I use marksmenship as a way of working through my PTSD. That's why I own them and I'm saddened that you seem to view us as fat rednecks.

    I hope you find closure some day, and I encourage you to look at our side, lawful owners who didn't murder anyone.

  • "I will stand up for my son I will not rest until the murderer and his friends are charged I will tell these fat, single minded idiots that guns do kill. What are you protecting yourself from the chips and dip on your coffee table. Have another beer you ignoramous Aidan lived a good life he tried to make a difference, you gun lovers are a blight on our society. Sleep with your hand gun I am sure it brings you comfort instead of living a good and fulfilling life. Aidans mom elaine"

    Ma'am I sympathize with you, your son didn't deserve this, no one does. Unfortunately your comments here will alienate firearms owners who would otherwise be with you.

    I own long guns, many of them. And I use marksmenship as a way of working through my PTSD. That's why I own them and I'm saddened that you seem to view us as fat rednecks.

    I hope you find closure some day, and I encourage you to look at our side, lawful owners who didn't murder anyone.

  • For a long time, something about this gun debate has been bothering me. I think how much time and money has been spent fighting about guns! What if BOTH sides in the gun debate 'put down their arms' and worked together to end violence? Not just handgun violence, or violence against women or gang violence or whatever, but ALL violence! Before guns were invented, thugs and louts used whatever means available to victimize the weak, get what they wanted, and leave a swath of bodies and trauma in their wake. Until we realize that we need to deal with the root cause of all this, we will fight each other to 'win' on the issue of inanimate objects. Does fighting sound like winning to you? Just about every Canadian wants less violence. We all have common ground. What you do about that is tellingly up to you. Imagine living in a society not free of guns, but free of the urge to disrespect someone's life, or possessions. Deep down, I feel that we are wasting valuable time. If we continue to fight, we may well make this all worse, not better!

  • Sorry for your loss, no one deserves such tragedy.

    "Banning" handguns will only prevent those who are not inclined to break the law from acquiring them. It has been a criminal offence to possess an unregistered handgun since 1934, and the crime committed on our streets today is overwhelmingly committed using unregistered, illegal handguns.

    Time to focus on the problem. Criminals.

    Guns, unlike criminals, can be used to prevent and protect against crime--ask any police officer.

  • It is unbelievable that an evil violence can steal the life of this young man. More unbelievable that target shooters/gun owners think the issue is that they might be hurt in the loss of a hobby.Elaine didn''t suffer this type of loss "loss"- any mother would be tormented forevermore if her son was gunned down leaving a campus pub because some trouble making thug shot him in the back with a stolen handgun. Elaine and Aidan had never seen a hand gun, ever . Her son was a popular university athlete who had a drink with friends that night. He had a right to live. She had a right to her son.He was killed on a Canadian street and no one should have to compare her anguish to anyone’s opinion that they will be sad about the loss of a hobby . Grieving mothers don''t take up causes because they need a hobby. Uncaring and stupid slogans about people not guns killing people are a symptom of an uncaring society where people shrug and say there is nothing we can do about violence shattering the life of a law abiding mother. But we all can aggressively and even unkindly defend our target shooting hobby at her expense. An apathetic society that defends hobbies over life should not be surprised when evil has taken hold. We should thank the Elaine Lumleys and Susan Jessops for putting their grief aside to fight this evil for a safer world for our children. It’s not for themselves ; their sons are gone. Aidans Aunt

  • I am reading this part of the paper for the first time. Yes People kill people. Yes Guns kill people. You can believe what you like. My son is gone because a cold blooded killer shot him. Yes it is easy to get a gun, What are we going to do about it? The legal system protects the criminal, what are we going to do about it? I have been told to watch what I say, lawyers read the papers and the killer may not get a fair trial. What About Aidan who was there to protect him. His friends shut the car door on him, witnesses will not come forward they are scared, the killers friends will not give the name of the murderer. Who will stand up for Aidan. There is going to be a rally in Montreal November 18th at 2:00pm at McGill University at the main gates. I will stand up for my son I will not rest until the murderer and his friends are charged I will tell these fat, single minded idiots that guns do kill. What are you protecting yourself from the chips and dip on your coffee table. Have another beer you ignoramous Aidan lived a good life he tried to make a difference, you gun lovers are a blight on our society. Sleep with your hand gun I am sure it brings you comfort instead of living a good and fulfilling life. Aidans mom elaine

  • First of all, Ms. Lumley, I want to say how sadden I was to read about the loss of your son. It was obviously a loss that should have never happened and hopefully the man who fired the gun will be found and prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law. Secondly, I do have to say that I do happen to agree with Mr. Lamarche in that "guns don't kill people, people kill people". It won't matter if handguns are outlawed because the bad people will still have access to them through the black market. It's just like drugs. Just because they are illegal doesn't stop people from getting them and using them. It's just the way it works. Drugs should definately be illegal but guns are also used for other things such as hunting and self-defense in our own homes and should not be taken away from those who are responsible enough to use them. Should we outlaw alcohol because people sometimes die from alcohol poisening? No, of course not. That would be ridiculous. Again, our prayers are with Ms. Lumley and her family. God Bless.

  • I am truly saddened and shocked. I knew Aidan Lumley since he was a young child. He was my brother, Eric's good friend all through elementary school and beyond. I am glad that I had the pleasure to know someone as outsanding as Aidan in my lifetime. I would always see him at the gym and he would approach me with his infectious and invigorating smile. He would work out beside me and he made me feel so at ease. Believe me! I hate working out and Aidan really made it so fun and enjoyable. He made the time go by so fast with his witty charm, good looks, humour and charisma. To Elaine, I am truly so sorry for your loss. I dont have to tell you Aidan was an accomplished and amazing young man. You did a wonderful job in raising him and you should be so proud as Im sure you are. I cant believe this happened, it doesnt make any sense. I hope will all my heart they find the psychotic coward who did this to him. As for MARTIN LAMARCHE with his innapropriate comment on gun control. I find you to be ignorant and rude. You should have more respect for Mrs Lumley and her loss. Maybe if someone killed your child with a gun, you would feel different about your ridiculous theory on guns. For the record, GUNS DO KILL PEOPLE, look at Aidan's story and many others. Do you really need more proof?

  • I am part of todays youth who happened to know Aidan as a child. Not only did he make a impact on my life as a child his passing away has been hard. Guns posses no point in this world , violence solves nothing it only leads to more violence, and I believe that if everyone stepped up and helps Aidan's mom even if it is just a little, together we can make a difference, and even if that change is small it may be enough to save a childs life. Say NO to guns and to viloence. And remember one day it may affect you closer to home than you ever thought, so while you have the chace make a difference.

  • Defend yourself from what?

  • I think that due to the nature of this article, people should have some respect. This Mother lost her only Son. And on top of that, the person responsible was never caught. Put yourself in her shoes. Would you just sit around and do nothing?

  • I am so fedup with poeple that blaim guns for all the killings. GUNS DON'T KILL PEOPLE, PEOPLE KILL PEOPLE. Gun control will not do nothing but take the guns out of the hands of the honest people. Do you think for one minute that the criminal will not have a gun because it's illigal. I don't think so. What we need is stiffer sentences for people that commit crimes with guns. If most people had the right to have guns in the home that were not all locked up, the ones that commit home invasions might think twice. Let us protect and defend ourselves. Thank you Martin Lamarche

FacebookTwitterRSSVideophotoNewsletterMobile