Gélinas convinced trip to Brazil will help to end strike

Dec 11, 2009- 2:20 PM

Bartolucci criticizes Gélinas for trip

By: Heidi Ulrichsen - Sudbury Northern Life

Nickel Belt MPP France Gélinas said she "doesn't want to give any false hope" to striking Steelworkers Local 6500 members, but she is convinced her recent trip to Brazil will help to resolve the union's strike against Vale Inco.

Gélinas visited Brazil this week along with Steelworkers Canadian national president Ken Neumann, Steelworkers Local 6500 vice-president Rick Bertrand and Steelworkers Local 9508 president Darren Cove (who represents 120 striking workers in Voisey's Bay).

Vale S.A., the parent company of Vale Inco, is based in Brazil. About 3,500 workers are on strike against Vale Inco in Canada in Sudbury and Port Colborne, Ont. and in Voisey's Bay, Nfld.

The MPP said she was able to meet with many different Brazilian politicians during the trip and speak with them about the strikes.

She was not able to meet with Brazilian president Luiz Inacio da Silva in person, despite earlier statements saying she wished to do so, but she did speak with an aide who is his right-hand man, according to media reports.

"I am convinced that it will make a difference. It will make a difference to bring both parties to the table faster," she said, speaking to Northern Life from Brazil on Dec. 10, shortly before her flight back to Canada.

"The different government officials that I met don't like what's happening to the image of Brazil, not only in Sudbury, Ont., but also worldwide. The Steelworkers have taken their fight outside of Canada."

Gélinas said the government officials are also unhappy that Vale has invested $19 billion in its Sudbury operations since it bought Inco in 2006, but that investment hasn't shown any returns in the five months since Local 6500 has been on strike.

The MPP was also present at a meeting between the Steelworkers and Brazilian Senator Paulo Paim. The Steelworkers said Vale officials were supposed to be at the meeting, but failed to show up. Vale Inco spokesperson Steve Ball said Vale officials were never asked to go to the meeting in the first place.

"To me, that was really weird," said Gelinas. "Why weren't they (Vale officials) there?"

Gélinas said it was the provincial leader of the NDP, Andrea Horwath, who was originally invited by the Steelworkers to visit Brazil.

However, Horwath was unable to come, and Gélinas decided to go instead.

Because she didn't have the money to pay for the trip, the national Steelworkers office offered to pay for her economy-class plane ticket to Brazil and her accommodations.

Gélinas said she paid for all other expenses during the trip.

Sudbury MPP Rick Bartolucci sent out a press release Dec. 10 criticizing Gélinas for going to Brazil.

"Rather than represent her constituents in the Ontario Legislature, Nickel Belt MPP France Gelinas opted to miss a key vote on Ontario’s improved taxation system in favour of raising false hopes among local striking workers," the press release said.

"Workers paid for much of Gélinas’ expenses to go to Brazil to talk to Vale Inco executives – something that didn’t happen."

Bartolucci said if Gélinas had checked beforehand, she would have known that she couldn't meet with the president of Brazil, because he is currently out of the country.

"If Gélinas wants to go on a wild goose chase, she should do it on her own dime and on her own time," stated the press release.

"She should reimburse workers and apologize for creating false hope for a resolution that predictably, did not occur. In the meantime, while playing international diplomat, Gélinas missed 23 votes in the house."

Read More: Home > Sudbury News

Reader's Feedback

Editor’s Note:

NorthernLife.ca may contain content submitted by readers, usually in the form of article comments. All reader comments and any opinions, advice, statements or other information contained in any messages posted or transmitted by any third party are the responsibility of the author of that message and not of NorthernLife.ca. The fact that a particular message is posted on or transmitted using this web site does not mean that NorthernLife.ca has endorsed that message in any way or verified the accuracy, completeness or usefulness of any message. We encourage visitors to NorthernLife.ca to report any objectionable content by using the "report abuse" link found in the comments section of this web site.

14 Comments

  • Clear and curtly summed up Mr.drifter.
    You summed up the entire labour dispute without mudslinging or making inflammatory remarks. "Just the facts ma'am."

    Stripping the union of rhetoric and emotional drivel, THAT's what the Steelworkers built their action upon. The knee-jerk reaction is an immediate dismissal with no logic. Just insults.

    To use a parallel scenario: Imagine owning a profitable company with multiple franchises. The corporation makes billions, but one store is burdened with legacy costs and an outdated bonus system. It loses money. There are few buyers for the products produced at your stores .The workers go on strike, despite being the clear cause of being in the red.

    They call you greedy because, as the owner, you refuse to prop up their store with the profits from you other holdings. The shareholders, many of them Mutual Fund and Stockholders,(everyday people) demand a profitable organization.
    You offer a decent contract during a global downturn. To keep things going. Tell the union, sign, come back when things improve. We'll talk then.

    They accuse you of being greedy. Make racist remarks and walk away. Then conjure up wild conspiracies to try and get anyone behind their cause. Believe they are entitled to special treatment.
    Your only response now is to explore how to replace the 10% of your output with other means.

  • Drifter, all of your drivel amounts to GREEDY Vale! There is no way that they can justify their actions. If that is what you worship, I pity you. BTW, I am not affected by this strike.

  • The nickel bonus was designed and offered by Inco to the union in 1985 when Inco controlled the world nickel market and depended on Sudbury for its income. The company had no money and needed to settle the strike. None of these conditions are true today.
    The company's offer in July with the new formula for calculating nickel bonus payouts reflected this new reality.

    Miners bonus has never been negotiable or grievable because it is a bonus.

    When Vale says they made a jillion dollars but the Sudbury operations of their subsidiary Vale Inco lost money, they have the right (even an obligation to their shareholders) to insist that each of their "profit centres" are profitable and take appropriate action if they are not. This is the sad truth of conglomerates and multinationals.

  • Person, that's a nice comment hoping that the guys are out past spring. Shows what kind of a human being you are. And if you think that France donated tax money to the USW, it's time to cut back on your meds a bit.
    One thing that really bugs me about all of this is the bonus. Vale is crying unsustainability, the bonus has nothing to do with this. It was negotiated for a long time ago. If the company doesn't do well, the workers don't either. It has nothing to do with the recession. Vale is being a GREEDY PIG.

  • Can someone enlighten me? I obviously missed this news development.How much money,and where did it come from.............that Gelinas is donating to the local?

  • Like watching a train wreck in slow motion from a mile away.

    We can't begin to fathom how it must feel to self destruct in such a slow, drawn out manner.
    Solidarity must offer some comfort....

  • To all you that insist on criticizing, what have you done to help bring the strike to an end....nothing!!!!!!!!, thats what I thought.

  • This is the third time I've mentioned this info......I got it from a usually reliable source...

    Leo (Lost Another One) Gerard and John (The Bus Driver) Rodriguez were seat mates on a plane from Toronto to Sudbury Thursday pm.

    Where was France G? Catching some rays in Rio with the USW of America lightweights.

  • I don't want to give any false hope, but here's some false hope! Oh Gelinas.

    If her visit did ANYTHING to effect this strike, then I'll be impressed. Unfortunately, I don't think that some MPP from a city no where near Brazil is going to change anything. She didn't even meet with Vale's president. This most likely failed mission just cost the workers even more money. That's money they don't have to throw away right now, and it's tragic.

  • Gelinas has become a paid puppet for a deep pocketed international organization. They bought her loyalty with a plane ticket and hotel room.

    Hummm, something the NDP accuse OTHER political parties of doing.
    Too bad she isn't back in Ontario, representing the other 180,000+ people in Sudbury.

  • Seems like everybody in Greater Sudbury thinks they know when the Vale Inco strike will end.
    I say the strike will end by February 16th,2010.
    What's your guess?

  • You are right Rick.Gelinas is spending a lot of money for nothing.Gelinas is not doing the job that she has to do.What a waste of money.It certainly will not stop the Union strike.She is a MPP and should stay in Toronto with the other NDP members in the Ontario Legislature.She will not help the Union members go back to work.I'm glad that she is not my MPP.

  • There's a rumour around that the Bus Driver was on a plane coming from Toronto and he was with Leo Gerard..pretty reliable source...
    Is Leo (Follow me to the Wilderness) Gerard in Sudbury?

  • Rick Bartolucci is acting more and more like a moron everyday. Rick is mad that France is doing her job? Rick did you forget that you skipped out on the anti-scab legislation? Rick you should go and hide out now like Roger Agnelli. I imagine the comments you just made will land you in a pile of you know what...

FacebookTwitterRSSVideophotoNewsletterMobile