Gélinas calls on ministries to monitor smelter situation

Dec 23, 2009- 4:06 PM

By: Sudbury Northern Life Staff

A letter sent to Copper Cliff homes about the de-riming process at the oxygen plant on Dec. 11 has prompted several residents to contact Nickel Belt NDP MPP France Gélinas with their concerns.

In response, Gélinas has written an open letter to three Ministers concerning the smelter. Rick Bartolucci, the Minister of Community Safety and Correctional Services as well as Sudbury MPP; Peter Fonseca, the Minister of Labour; and John Gerretsen, the Minister of the Environment, were the addressees.

In her letter, Gélinas reminded the ministers of the 1995 sulfur trioxide leak from the acid plant, which sent hundreds of people to the hospital. The acid plant would need to be restarted should smelting operations resume, along with the oxygen plant.

She said residents are concerned smelter operations, which are "highly technical and dangerous," will be undertaken by replacement workers without experience in the responsibilities.

Gélinas called this a 'ticking time bomb,' and called on the ministers to answer the concerns of her constituents that the process will be safe and carefully monitored by government officials.

In her letter, she asked if the smelter operation is being monitored 24-7, with inspectors on site from the three ministries. Gélinas also requested that a contact number for residents as well as her office be made available, so concerned individuals can have concerns addressed.

"People in my constituency need to be reassured that the operations are safe and are being continually monitored by government officials," wrote Gélinas.

"This goes beyond solely a labour dispute. This is about community safety and about preventing injuries and irreversible environmental damage."

In the letter to Copper Cliff residents, dated Dec. 11, Steve Ball, Vale Inco's manager of Corporate Affairs, explained the type of activity occuring at the Copper Cliff smelter.

"As part of the smelter restart, the #4 Oxygen Plant in Copper Cliff will need to undergo a de-riming process. A de-rime is essentially a defrosting of the cold sections of the oxygen plant in order to remove moisture, carbon dioxide, and other contaminants."

He also wrote "a restart date has not been officially determined at this time."

Gélinas said she wants Vale Inco and the three ministries to provide daily information about any possible inspection and safety issues.

"It is not business as usual and

people are worried," she said.
Read More: Home > Sudbury News

Reader's Feedback

Editor’s Note:

NorthernLife.ca may contain content submitted by readers, usually in the form of article comments. All reader comments and any opinions, advice, statements or other information contained in any messages posted or transmitted by any third party are the responsibility of the author of that message and not of NorthernLife.ca. The fact that a particular message is posted on or transmitted using this web site does not mean that NorthernLife.ca has endorsed that message in any way or verified the accuracy, completeness or usefulness of any message. We encourage visitors to NorthernLife.ca to report any objectionable content by using the "report abuse" link found in the comments section of this web site.

6 Comments

  • This has nothing to do with safety. Its about payback to her political financial supporters. Why would Inco and the 3 Ministries waste the time to report to her on a daily basis.

  • Not necessarily grandstanding. She may have moved to Copper Cliff.

  • Political grandstanding at its best. She makes it sound like the Ministry of Labour and Environment don't have a job to do ever day monitoring what they do at the Smelter. Give it a rest.

    As for you noofie - FYI there are 5 months worth of concentrate/feed sitting on the ground at the Smelter from what I hear. You don't think they wasted the opportunity to stockpile last year when things were slow?

  • Me cousin George is just down from Thompson. He works in the smelter there and he's laughin to spill his rum at ye.

    No way Vale Inco can start the smelter up cause they got no feed for her. He says they got to get some heat to the furnaces to cure the brick lining (he called them reefer ractories) and stuff like that there but there's no feed for them so he figures the union is just trying to keep the guys on the line feedin wood to the barrels and maybe scare some old folks in Copper Cliff.

    Now I'm thinkin after Jan 15 it's a different kettle of fish specially if the boys in Labrador sign up and get back to mining.

    But this here France one.......she's along fer the ride. She fixed me shoulder oncet when I hurt he stockin shelves at the 7-11 and she was working as a massager and I dint think much of her then.

  • how about we start asking the same questions? someone had to cause you know damn well Clement doesn't give 2 wet farts about Sudbury or its citizens. whether or not you support the strike, what if these warnings end up being true? like it or not, there is a danger no matter who is manning the place. do i feel safer when its people who've been running the place for years without any major disasters that could affect my health? of course. do i still feel safe if there's a chance the people they chose to run it don't have the know how or experience to run it safely? that's an easy one.
    if VALE is hell bent on running it without 6500, then the very least they can do is truck in people who have done it before for years, safely, and provide the necessary on the job training to ensure that the population of Sudbury is not hanging in the balance. the other 145k people who are not involved in this dispute have every right to reside here safely regardless of shareholder profits and share prices. class action lawsuits are worthless once you're dead or cancer stricken.

  • let's all chill out let fate run its course and whatever happens happens

FacebookTwitterRSSVideophotoNewsletterMobile