Budget shortfall leads to cuts at Cambrian

Cambrian College president Sylvia Barnard announced cuts to maintenance and daycare at a press conference April 14. The cuts are necessary to help the college cope with a $7.5 million operating budget shortfall. File photo.

Cambrian College president Sylvia Barnard announced cuts to maintenance and daycare at a press conference April 14. The cuts are necessary to help the college cope with a $7.5 million operating budget shortfall. File photo.

Apr 14, 2010- 2:05 PM

Axe hits day care, maintenance

By: Heidi Ulrichsen - Sudbury Northern Life Staff

Cambrian College president Sylvia Barnard announced April 14 that the institution is making a number of cuts and changes to the way it operates in order to deal with a $7.5 million operating budget shortfall, which represents 10 per cent of its operating budget.

These changes came about after the college conducted an extensive review of its programs, beginning in the fall of 2009. The college will be presenting its budget in May.

The college's board of governors has approved a document called Achieving Long-Term Sustainable Financial Health, which “provides a decision-making model, and a framework, along with principles around how the college would move forward into better sustainability for our finances,” Barnard said.

The college will be closing its day care centre as of June 30, putting five child care workers and one manager out of a job. The day care centre, which has 51 spaces, about 40 of which are occupied by the children of students, is projected to run a $250,000 deficit in 2010-11, Barnard said.

“With...expansions on campus now completed, we feel that we can afford to move to a more streamlined and cost-effective maintenance model, that doesn't require as many workers.”

Sylvia Barnard,
Cambrian College president

Maintenance operations at the college are also being restructured, resulting in six maintenance workers, and two managers losing their jobs.

Barnard said the college compared its maintenance staff with that of other colleges in the province, and found that its numbers were substantially higher.

“With...expansions on campus now completed, we feel that we can afford to move to a more streamlined and cost-effective maintenance model, that doesn't require as many workers.”

The college will save $250,000 a year from closing down its day care centre, and $950,000 a year from reducing its maintenance workforce.

Beyond these measures, Cambrian has also introduced the President's Committee of Financial Health, which is made up of college employees, and brings ideas to Barnard about how the college can operate more efficiently and reduce duplication.

The college is also offering an early retirement incentive program, increasing its parking rates, established an ancillary business co-operative (where college businesses outside of the college's primary operations co-operate to learn how to attract more business), and hiring a private management company to operate the college's residences.

Barnard said she hopes that putting a management company in charge of the residences will result in these facilities being used when students aren't living there. Both this company and the college would get a cut of these funds, she said.

She said she could not reveal how much this contract is worth because they are currently putting together a request for proposals.

Beyond these measures, Barnard said students can expect to see about a four per cent increase in tuition. Six programs with low enrolment have already been suspended by the college, she said.

The $7.5 million budget shortfall was caused by a number of factors, Barnard said. In 2008, the Ministry of Training, Colleges and Universities changed the funding model for colleges, which has resulted in a decrease in the base funding for Cambrian College.

As well, the college has to absorb about $4 million per year in additional costs due to inflation, collective agreement requirements and increased cost for services.

The downturn in the economy has resulted in a loss of revenue from the college's corporate and contract training businesses. Lastly, Cambrian is replacing its Student Information System, which is a multi-year, multi-million dollar project.

Read More: Home > Sudbury News

Reader's Feedback

Editor’s Note:

NorthernLife.ca may contain content submitted by readers, usually in the form of article comments. All reader comments and any opinions, advice, statements or other information contained in any messages posted or transmitted by any third party are the responsibility of the author of that message and not of NorthernLife.ca. The fact that a particular message is posted on or transmitted using this web site does not mean that NorthernLife.ca has endorsed that message in any way or verified the accuracy, completeness or usefulness of any message. We encourage visitors to NorthernLife.ca to report any objectionable content by using the "report abuse" link found in the comments section of this web site.

27 Comments

  • I think you'd better check your facts Phillip, as you as mistaken. Or perhaps you are a pot stirrer or paid blogger..Either way, research your facts.

  • Budget shortfall, if school presidents and there board would stop wasting good money on dumb ideas they wouldn't have shortfalls. Like giving out money to foreign students and dont tell me that they dont doo it because i have conections at cambrien and boreal and i got the low down, plus why should these school's administrations get such big saleries they dont do squat, like the president at boreal he gets tones of cash and it's other people who do all the work for him, this also from good sources. Also there is this thing about day care if i get this right cambrien is not happy with the day care situation at there campus, or something like that so thats why the province is starting to take away space in other schools to make place for new day care locations.

  • Sorry Charlie.
    But student tuition goes into the college's general revenues. As well as provincial tax collected from you and me goes to the government to have a portion doled out to colleges and universities.
    All the funds are then allocated for the COMPLETE budget. Which includes the babysitting center.

    There is no difference between babysitting and daycare. The doublespeak of actively educating children in formative years is pure BS.
    Daycare is a large group of toddlers and infants that are watched while they colour in books, take naps, play on the swings, and run amok as the 2 or 3 'care workers' herd them like cats.
    They do the exact same thing your single sitter does. But with far less personal attention. Having a piece of paper stating you spent 10 grand in a year to learn how to watch children doesn't automatically make a person an expert child watcher. And the only reason the Ministry of Community and Social Services had to step in to govern it was from the rare problem home cares.

    Bottom line is the service should not be paid for by the public and other students. You know that.

  • Phillip

    A portion of city taxes goes both toward school systems and daycare subsidies. Student tuition does not.

    There is a big difference between daycare and paid babysitting.

    Daycare Centers and Licensed Home Child Cares actively educate young children in their formative years and are governed by the Ministry of Community and Social Services.

  • Bottom line is that taxpayers and student tuition should not be supporting paid babysitting.
    You choose to go to a post-secondary institution, then you should pay for your own child watching arrangements.

    OSAP, loans, and grants are all out there. And just where are the family members and friends of these parents?
    Babysitting services (aka daycare) are tax deductible as well. You'll get that cash back.
    College and university is an investment in yourself. Not a given right. You want to play, you gotta pay.
    Also, I know of many students that are in the school for a few hours, here and there. They have their kids in daycare all day, every day. - What's the cost of that?

  • Cambrian Prez should take a 10% pay cut...this will save the DAYCARE...Anyone making over 200,000 a year is a little greedy...A Prez of a small college can afford because, it don't take that much money to shop at Walmart....

  • Cambrian Prez should take a 10% pay cut...this will save the DAYCARE...Anyone making over 200,000 a year is a little greedy...A Prez of a small college can afford because, it don't take that much money to shop at Walmart....

  • Great job Prez!!! With these kinds of decisions you are insuring more staff hitting the sunshine list and you closing in on 300k. Elitist isn't it? Have you ever been down to the daycare and seen how demanding their work is or worked a day in the shoes of support staff? Not really sure what you do there how does your day look like?

  • i have to live within my means why do governments and others think that piling up continous debt loads will work out long term. it leads to higher taxes da. crasdle to grave soacilist policies are a recipe for disaster. take a look at your future it looks bleak doesnt it. i wonder why?

  • This is ridiculous. Cambrian, as well as all the other educational institutions have been pushing for years for people to advance their education. There are several people out there who require day care just to go to school. What about the single mother or father who don't have a car??? The salaries of these professors have been spiraling out of control. I'm not saying tha they don't deserve to get paid well, I'm just asking the quesion "do they really need to get paid as much as they do?". I agree with almost everyone who have said this is just a smoke screen.

    Oh...and what about their ECE program? No daycare to practice their skills or learn from people that have practical experience?? I am a mother and would hate for my child to be in the care of a recent grad that had no practical experience. Book knowledge can teach you theory...but hands on experience is the key!

  • I hear ya lovelygurl..I love my job and grateful for it.I am just saying of all the cutbacks they could choose from there are many more they could choose that have nothing to do with the actual education aspect of the college...

  • http://theshield.cambrianc.on.ca/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=780:sun-shining-brighter-at-cambrian&catid=8:cambriannews&Itemid=54

    "The annual ‘Sunshine List’ has been released and Cambrian College has seen the number of its staff appearing on the list increase compared to last year’s tally.

    The list, in accordance with the Public Sector Salary Disclosure Act, includes the names, positions and total taxable benefits of any employee making over $100,000 or more in a calendar year while working for an organization receiving public funding from the Province of Ontario.

    This year Cambrian has 47 staff members on the list, up from 35 in 2009."

    12 join the club in ONE YEAR........

  • I do not think that closing the daycare is the appropriate thing to do. How many big wigs are at the college...you have Vp of this, VP of that, President of this,associate vice president of that.And they all make over $100,000 a year. Sarah, closing the pub is not a good idea, you would be out of a job. The Student Centre is there for the students. You drink there too.

  • Yes that is expensive .But when you look at how many Superintentands alone they have (over 21) making in excess of $125,000 dollars plus perks.They close daycare????
    You figure.

  • Look at things in a business perspective, $250,000 cost for 40 students who use the facility breaks down to $6,250 for each of those 40 students. That is an expensive service for only 40 students. I am not saying it is right, I am just poiunting out the facts.

  • Look at things in a business perspective, $250,000 cost for 40 students who use the facility breaks down to $6,250 for each of those 40 students. That is an expensive service for only 40 students. I am not saying it is right, I am just poiunting out the facts.

  • Also they need to take into consideration that many parents looking to go to college will resort to other cities that have on campus daycare, Cambrian will be losing money, also the majority of children enrolled there are funded by the government anyways..... arggg

  • I am a single mother who has been attending Cambrian College for two years now,I am studying Civil Engineering I will be enrolled there for two more years,I am also employed at the college. My son has attended the Play and Learn Daycare also for two years. That daycare is a blessing, as I can not afford a vehicle, being a single parent student. The staff has taken great care of my son throughout the years. I think this is ridiculous, on Tuesday the representatives of Cambrian College were featured in an article in the Northern Life addressing the fact that colleges and universities, especially in Sudbury need to be working together to benefit the students, because of the aging population and lack of education in our province, here is a prime example of hard working parents pursuing their education and now Cambrian is going to make our process that much more difficult. Words and actions conflicting yet again, I am sincerly disappointed in this decision,, why don't they cut out the arcade which sits empty racking up huge electricity bills? Close the pub which gives students a place to sit and drink their OSAP money and brain cells away all day??? If it had not been for the daycare being located right beside Cambrian it may have never been possible for me to pursue my education...As Jackal stated $250,000 on daycare is a smokescreenand a real insult to me who works hard at school and for the school...

  • I am not taking any sides on this issue, DarrenL, you may want to consider that student fees are actually formed by two parts. Part one is the tuition fee, and part two is the ancillary fee. The tuition fees may have increased by 4% and the other increase may have been through the ancillary fees. Therefore the president could be accurate in stating that tuition will increase by 4%. On the subject of difference between College fees and University fees, it has long existed that some college programs carry a higher student fee than those in University. It all depends on the equipement, lab support etc. that the program entails.

  • They say that the tuition is increasing by 4% but that is either a calculated lie or an error. I just found the 2010/2011 tuition fees for my son's program and it has been increased almost 10%. An additional $400 or so is much higher than inflation and so much higher that what anyone might consider as reasonable. The total cost for year-one of my son's college program is now higher than if he had chosen to attend Laurentian University! (Yes, I checked.) A real nice surprise after taking a 20% drop in the RESP that we worked so very hard to pay into for the past 10 years. This nearly 10% tuition increase is a nice punch in the groin. Thanks Cambrian.

  • This decision needs full review. In a multi-million dollar facility, saving $250,000 on daycare is a smokescreen and is a real insult to everyone who reads this story.
    The problem with too many institutions in Sudbury is they are all top-heavy with Presidents, CEO's, CFO's, and deputies to everything and assistants to everything else and huge 'sunshine' salaries to go along with the job.
    Its time to cut from the top - not the bottom! Roll back the top salaries ten to twenty percent for starters. I do not begrudge Sylvia Bernard making $265,000 per year, but its way too much in these economic times and for a place like Sudbury. And its not the salaries, its the benefits.The pension plan, the health plan and so on. Quit sticking it to the students - they pay and suffer enough.

  • Reallocation of funds is the solution to most funding problems. Naturally, those who are supportive employees of the institution’s purpose are the first to consider. This leads us to “administrative personnel” first, and as luck would have it, they are handsomely paid. Therefore, a 30 to 40 percent reduction in remuneration of all administration personnel, including the president, should take up any slake in education funding.

    There need not be any fear of anyone quitting their jobs as a result of my proposed reallocation recommendation because where would they go?

  • As a former employee of cambrian college I know first hand how they cut from the little guys first. It was about 1994-95 that they took away vacation pay and stat holiday pay from part-time workers.We were told by the labor board that because they fall under a "SPECIAL" umbrella it was allowed.So we were making sweat shop wages.I say cut from the president on down and you would have enough monies to keep the daycare open.This move is very shameful I will not promote the college again.

  • I agree with jigsaw! Why not take money cuts/freeze from the top of the rung staff? That's where the big money is. I know they work for their money too but come on! The rich get richer, the poor get poorer.... Instead they are going to force students who have young kids to go somewhere else that has day care on site. I can't see students who have no vehicle (most) bussing their kid(s) to some other location, then bus to school and back again. They will probably more likely not even consider Cambrian because of it. Continuing an education is hard enough. They are now just making it harder to do it at Cambrian. Just wait, this decision is going to bite them back some day.

  • Good point Jigsaw. Applicable in other areas, where cost cutting somehow by-passes the brass.

  • How about freezing/cutting the salary of the top earners to help with the budget shortfall?

  • Funny how Cambrian is chasing away the kids from 0 to 4 years of age from its campus. Are they their future students. By doing this, they are making college life more difficult for students and staff to access day care services.
    Why is it that Laurentian, Boréal and the school boards are enhancing these services to better serve parents, increase the participation of parents in school, increase the training of students while Cambrian is blaming its deficit on defenseless children and its maintenance staff. Perhaps Cambrian should look at straightlining its programs, at eliminating the programs attracting too few students, and reducing the funds dedicated to managing the institution.

FacebookTwitterRSSVideophotoNewsletterMobile