'Out of a job for no reason'

Aug 19, 2010- 1:16 PM

Bypassed on recall list, Xstrata Nickel workers fight for jobs

By: Heidi Ulrichsen - Sudbury Northern Life Staff

Three years ago, Xstrata Nickel worker George McIvor was carrying a piece of heavy equipment after finishing a job, when he tripped and fell to his knees, injuring his back in two places.

“Ever since then, my life has gone downhill,” he said.

After his injury, the 56-year-old man worked at the company's modified work centre, making safety equipment. But in early 2009, McIvor and almost 700 workers found themselves out of a job after layoffs at Xstrata Nickel's Sudbury operations.

With the rebound in the economy and a new contract between Mine Mill Local 598/CAW, Xstrata Nickel started recalling some of the laid off workers earlier this year.

But McIvor, who was 28th on the recall list, said he was shocked when he was bypassed by the company in the recalls.

“On Monday, it will be five months that I've been bypassed on the recall list,” he said. “They're saying they don't have any work for me within my restrictions.”

Vicky and George McIvor have held protests in front of Xstrata Nickel plants almost every day for the past month. They were joined by about 30 supporters at a rally in front of the company's Nickel Rim South Mine during the evening of Aug. 18. McIvor, who was injured on the job about three years ago and laid off by the company in 2009, said he was not recalled by the company this year because of his injury. Photo by Heidi Ulrichsen.

Vicky and George McIvor have held protests in front of Xstrata Nickel plants almost every day for the past month. They were joined by about 30 supporters at a rally in front of the company's Nickel Rim South Mine during the evening of Aug. 18. McIvor, who was injured on the job about three years ago and laid off by the company in 2009, said he was not recalled by the company this year because of his injury. Photo by Heidi Ulrichsen.

McIvor and two other workers in the same position received support from about 30 community members at a rally held at the entrance to Xstrata's Nickel Rim South Mine during the evening of Aug. 18.

McIvor and his wife, Vicky, have held protests — most of them in the early morning — in front of Xstrata Nickel's Sudbury plants almost every day for the past month. Sometimes they stand on the side of the road alone, while at other times they receive support from community members.

He said the company, by law, has a duty to find work for injured workers.

While McIvor is currently out searching for another job, he said he's hopeful he and the other injured workers will get their jobs at Xstrata Nickel back soon.

Local 598 filed a grievance on behalf of the workers, and McIvor said he has a stage two grievance meeting with the company's human resources department at the end of August.

McIvor also filed a complaint regarding his situation earlier this month with the Ontario Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario.

The tribunal is designed to deal with claims of discrimination under the Ontario Human Rights Code.

Representatives of Xstrata Nickel were not immediately available to comment on the issue.

However, Peter Fuchs, Xstrata Nickel's director of corporate affairs, told Northern Life in an e-mail in July that all employers in Ontario, including Xstrata Nickel, are bound by provincial legislative requirements to accommodate injured workers.

“We not only comply with such requirements and with our collective agreements, but we take such matters very seriously,” he said.

Another injured worker who was laid off by Xstrata Nickel in 2009 spoke to Northern Life at the rally on the condition of anonymity.

He said he was hurt just four days before the layoffs, but has worked hard to recover from his injury, losing 50 pounds and regaining his range of motion.

He has a message for those who are currently working for Xstrata Nickel — work safe and don't get hurt.

“If you get hurt, you're no good to nobody,” he said. “If you're doing something unsafe for the company, it's not worth it. You'll just be in the same position that I am — out of a job for no reason.” 

Read More: Home > Sudbury News

Reader's Feedback

Editor’s Note:

NorthernLife.ca may contain content submitted by readers, usually in the form of article comments. All reader comments and any opinions, advice, statements or other information contained in any messages posted or transmitted by any third party are the responsibility of the author of that message and not of NorthernLife.ca. The fact that a particular message is posted on or transmitted using this web site does not mean that NorthernLife.ca has endorsed that message in any way or verified the accuracy, completeness or usefulness of any message. We encourage visitors to NorthernLife.ca to report any objectionable content by using the "report abuse" link found in the comments section of this web site.

12 Comments

  • Mr. McIvor
    You have asked for our support and held your demonstrations along our road to work, asking for ???????

    What is it you can do in terms of work?
    Can you return to a full, unqualified job?
    What is the WSIB saying?
    Surely, if you have a case to return to work, they'll be anxious to get you off their "payroll"
    Is there something you're not sharing with NL or us?

  • Well,cynnical,my post was removed also.Just beginning to wonder why the Northern Life allow Noof/Phil to operate with impunity,while removing ours.Considering their posts are usually saturated with insults,im beginning to wonder if we are playing on a level field

  • HAHAHAHAHAAHAHHA........who's the whiner that had my post removed?Typical......windbags!

  • Ok cynnical, we all may agree that McIvor and his supporters are up to something. And that there's more to his story than he portrays.
    But to call them windbags and kiddies is a bit offside.

  • @Madmyx
    I agree. Correctologists or Eesodynamics do wonders. If you are in a group of 10 adults in Sudbury, at least one will have a miracle story about these guys

  • OMG...listen to the spiew. Plain and Simple. See a Correctologist (not a chiropractor) and for a few $40 visits your fixed, pain free and you can get your ass back to work. Trust me... I'm a genious.

  • In a lot of cases companies will provide light duty work to an injured worker to avoid a WSIB claim and a subsequent increase in premiums. Something needs to be done to put an end to insurance, bank and government supported extortion.

  • @ George McIvor
    Why are you doing these demonstrations at Xstrata sites?

    Why don't you do a demo at the WSIB office? If your injury is registered as an injury occurring at work, your payment should be quickly settled on. If not, your MPP should be picketted also.

    What is it you're not telling us George?
    Heidi may be naive enough to believe you but don't bs us.

  • You are hurt on the job, then the company must find you work. Probably the weight was put on cause he is not as active as he was before his injury. You keep fighting George, these companies think all employees are a number.

  • Did he file a WISIB claim? If so, then he's entitled to coverage. Unless he took a disability payout and now regrets that quick money.
    Bottom line here is that there are no jobs for McIvor. Xstrata, or any company for that matter, doesn't have to manufacture a job for him. Simply put, the posisitons are for full, able bodied people.
    There is no discrimination here. Sorry pal, the union mentality of being entitled to special treatment doesn't fit anymore.

  • George, If you lost some weight, alot of weight it could do wonders for your back.
    If you got hurt at work, you must be on WSIB, right? Perhaps there are a few things you aren't disclosing.

  • Hope Xstrada them sends him back to school for Corrections to get a cushy job as security guard. This would make a good modified job for him.

FacebookTwitterRSSVideophotoNewsletterMobile