Immigration? Oui!

Feb 01, 2012- 2:21 PM

Foreign francophone workers filling need in Sudbury shops

By: Northern Ontario Business Staff

Robert Brouillette shakes his head in disbelief when recalling the challenges he’s faced while trying to retain employees at his family’s Sudbury business.

Specializing in custom welding projects for mining and other industries, City Welding has been in business for 40 years, but the last few have been especially challenging.

He just can’t get employees willing to work.

“I had a guy say he’s going out to his truck to get something, and he packs his bags and leaves,” Brouillette said incredulously. ”I look around and he’s gone.”

Frustrated by workers who didn’t show up on time, were lured away by the competition, or simply disappeared without notice, Brouillette began looking elsewhere for an alternative.

In Destination Canada, he found an answer.

An initiative of the federal government, the annual overseas job fair matches foreign, francophone workers with Canadian small business owners who are seeking to add to their workforce.

At its inception 10 years ago, the program sent government representatives abroad to explore the foreign worker market, but within the last few years, business owners have made the trip, enabling them to interview and test potential employees on site for suitability to their companies.

It’s an especially good opportunity for northern Ontarians to boost the profile of the North overseas, where Canada is best known by “MTV:” Montreal, Toronto and Vancouver.

Brouillette, who also holds a law degree, made his first trip to Tunisia last year, where he interviewed prospective workers and put them through their welding paces. The result was a welcome surprise.

“In Europe, they get into the training schools at 15 instead of 17,” he said. “They’re encouraged to get out into the market and start working, so the level of maturity and responsibility is higher than in Canada. Someone 28 already has 10 or 12 years of experience.”

To qualify for the program, Canadian businesses are thoroughly researched and must demonstrate that they can’t fill a vacancy at their company. The government covers the cost of their trip, arranging interviews with candidates who have made the shortlist.

Successful candidates are required to sign a contract for up to three years, and the visa granted to them is applicable only for the company that hires them — they can be sent home if they don’t meet expectations, try to get a job elsewhere, or enrol in school instead.

Since his initial experience, Brouillette has added to his staff 11 foreign workers — from Romania, the Philippines and Tunisia — and he has been consistently impressed by their strong work ethic, loyalty and flexibility.

Brouillette was so pleased with the results of the program he passed on the word to other business owners in the city. This past November, he returned for Destination Canada 2011 with five other business owners in tow.

Over 12 days, they travelled to Paris, Brussels and Tunisia to meet with potential employees.

Brouillette’s experience, it turned out, was not isolated. Trevor Gamache, who operates Crowe’s Mobile, has been advertising for mechanics on the online federal job bank steadily for two years. But his search had gone unfulfilled.

Gamache has been disappointed with the quality of workers who apply: they quit after an hour on the job, or balked at doing dirty, hands-on work. He had to move pay day to Monday because employees were leaving after collecting a paycheque on Friday afternoon, never to return.

“I’m a hostage in my own shop,” Gamache said. “I have a guy who shows up at 8:30 every day for an 8 a.m. shift. I keep asking him to show up on time. He knows he can’t be fired because I need him to do the work.”

Breaking down on the side of the road may be an inconvenience for Gamache’s customers, but Lizette Wirta’s clients are much more vulnerable. Her business, Home Instead, offers personal home care services to older adults. When her workers don’t show up for a shift, her clients may sit in soiled diapers or go without a meal.

Yet, she’s had workers leave early on a Friday afternoon to get a jump on the weekend, leaving her clients in the lurch.

“These are seniors in need; they’re vulnerable people,” Wirta said. “I’d fire her, but who’s going to replace all her shifts? I can’t fire anybody. I have to be grateful for what they do do.”

Wirta has advertised in Toronto, where there is an abundance of personal support workers seeking employment, but initial expressions of interest soon fizzle when job seekers realize they have to move north for the position.

Workers from Quebec are equally unwilling to relocate.

The situation has actually reached crisis proportions for Wirta, who said she’d like to expand her business, but can’t take on any new clients because she doesn’t have the workers to service them.

“I’ve got 38 girls, but I could use 100,” she said. “You can’t grow your company if you can’t hire the staff.”

She’s since looked to Jamaica for help, and has hired several women from that country, who will be joining her firm shortly.

Immigration seems like a solution, but business owners are getting flack here at home. Accused of “stealing” jobs from Canadians, it’s been suggested they’re only going overseas to get cheap labour.

Not true, said Monique Forsyth, co-owner of Northern Voice & Data, who once had an employee give two hours’ notice before walking out the door for good. Destination Canada requires that prospective employers follow certain criteria to qualify for the program, including paying foreign workers the average wage for that position in the region.

“When I hire people, I look at it in such a way that they’re looking towards me to make sure that their mortgage is paid, their staples are taken care of and they’re fed,” Forsyth said. “When I hire someone, I make sure that it’s somebody that will be the proper person for the job.”

Forsyth said she and other business owners are not only fulfilling their own needs, but they’re bringing to Canada dedicated, skilled workers who are ready and willing to work, with the additional benefit of expanding the cultural diversity of the city.

Gamache agrees that bringing foreign workers to Canada is a big responsibility. But it’s worth it to find the right person for the job.

“I’ll pay top dollar for a guy who’s going to do top work, who’s going to show up on time,” Gamache said. “All I ask for you to do is come in, do your job on time, do your job the best you can do, and be safe. Do it every day for five days in a row, and at the end you get paid. I’m not asking for miracles.”

Brouillette fears if the competition for skilled workers escalates further, local businesses will price themselves out of labour and be forced to find cheaper manufacturing sources, like China.

To avoid that, Brouillette would like to see more services put into place that support immigrants, to boost retention and encourage them to stay. Hiring foreign workers is no panacea, “but it allows you to breathe,” he said.

Confirmation that he was following the right path came last Christmas when one of his Romanian workers approached him to thank him for bringing him to Canada where his granddaughter had been born three years earlier.

“People are grateful,” Brouillette said. “That’s one of my biggest things that I’ve been able to do that I’ve felt really good about over the last five years.”

Posted by Arron Pickard
Read More: Home > Sudbury News

Reader's Feedback

Editor’s Note:

NorthernLife.ca may contain content submitted by readers, usually in the form of article comments. All reader comments and any opinions, advice, statements or other information contained in any messages posted or transmitted by any third party are the responsibility of the author of that message and not of NorthernLife.ca. The fact that a particular message is posted on or transmitted using this web site does not mean that NorthernLife.ca has endorsed that message in any way or verified the accuracy, completeness or usefulness of any message. We encourage visitors to NorthernLife.ca to report any objectionable content by using the "report abuse" link found in the comments section of this web site.

19 Comments

  • Why doesn't he move to Romania or Indonesia with this crappy business and his trashing of his fellow Sudbury citizens and politicians. Hope none of the Big Business in town deal with this jerk. Hope his foreign workers are not slave labour. Hope the ministry of labour does a prompt inspection of his facilities, speak to all the employees and see if they get any vacation time and get yearly lung xrays due to the high asbestos nature and dust pollution in his business.

  • I read the rest of the article on Sudbury Star's site and it looks like he wants to relocate because of piss poor infrastructure where he is currently. As I said before, why not just move to a new location within the main part of the city. For the 2 million alone in water and sewer upgrades the city wants him to spend, he could get a vacant building and probably have more than enough left over to renovate.

  • And it's not always low pay that drives people away. I've had jobs in the past that were minimum wage or just barely above it and the people were happy. It all comes down to how the boss treats his workers.

  • Why the heck is it the local politicians to help this guy out with his company? It's one thing if he's an up and comer just starting out his business, I don't see a problem with that, but after 35 years you should be able to stand up on your own. If he wants to expand, why not just buy up some vacant industrial land. You could probably get it for just the back taxes owing if it were seized by the city.

    To not offer benefits to a welder or any skilled trademen is just asking for trouble. As already mentioned, benefits are key. Even a single guy with no kids needs them, even just basic dental and meds. If you want quality and dedicated loyal employees, then you have to pay. If you want a revolving door and high turnover, then continue to operate treating employees badly and don't offer them benefits.

  • 1+1=2
    Bad employer and high worker turn over rate=2
    1+2=3
    Bad employer and high turn over rate and blame local politicians=3
    1+3=4
    Bad employer and high turn over rate workers and blame local politicians and foreign employees that don't know their rights, can't speak English-have no safety training=Ministry of Labour checking out this bad employer
    This guy should also be checked out by the Legal Law Society.

  • 1+1=2
    Bad employer and high worker turn over rate=2
    1=2=3
    Bad employer and high turn over rate and blame local politicians=3
    1+3=4
    Bad employer and high turn over rate workers and blame local politicians and foreign employees that don't know their rights, can't speak English-have no safety training=Ministry of Labour checking out this bad employer

  • This Robert guy is a jerk and BAD BOSS/OWNER OF the YEAR. He BLAMED CITY POLITICIANS A YEAR AGO FOR HIS CRAPPY BUSINESS AND NOW HE BLAMES SUDBURY FOLKS AS BAD WORKERS. TIME FOR HIM TO GO TO ROMANIA OR WHEREVER WITH HIS BUSINESS. ANOTHER NOTE DON'T WANT HIM AS MY LAWYER WITH HIS HORRIBLE WORK ETHIC.

    By MIKE WHITEHOUSE THE SUDBURY STAR
    Posted 1 year ago
    A Sudbury businessman is threatening to move his company out of town citing an unresponsive local government.

    Rob Brouillette, general manager of City Welding in New Sudbury, said plans to expand his business by 30 to 40 employees in the next couple of years are on hold because the city's services are inadequate.

    The family-run business, founded by Brouillette's father, George, 34 years ago, employs about 40 people. But business has been so good, the company needs more space, equipment and employees, Brouillette said.

    Mining-related work accounts for 40% to 60% of the company's business and most of that is local, he said. But more of his business is coming from across Northern Ontario and as far away as Alberta.

  • City Welding is notorious for low wages, no benefits, and contravenes every labour law. All Canadian citizens give this employer a wide berth and he is left with no choice but to employ immigrants who do not know their rights and obligations. Time for Labour Ministry to come and close down this clown with all of his safety infractions.

  • ...cheap and unethical they can possibly go...

  • Employee's side of the story:

    Yes, a lot of employees are lazy. But a lot of employers are dumb. A lot of employers don't know how to hire and when they hire, they hire people they feel comfortable with. But being comfortable with someone rarely translates in getting a good employee. I used word "comfortable" on purpose.

    There are so many unemployed people on the streets. Many are good potential employees. Lets focus on those. Many of them are looking for a decent job with decent conditions and pay. Yet, they are unemployed or they are underemployed. Very few want to be on welfare and work under the table. Welfare provides 599$ a month and working under the table means no medical and other benefits. Therefore, there are a lot of people who want to work.

    The reason such portion of unemployed is overlooked is that, again, many employers don't know how to hire. And, they don't know how to motivate people. The easiest way to keep an employee work under conditions he or she disagrees with is fear. A local employee does not fall under pressure of fear and knows he/she has more options. Unfortunately, a foreign worker looks at an unethical Canadian employer as a rescuer from even worse conditions back in his own country. A foreign employee will stay with such employer for as long as it is needed to secure a stay in Canada. Once a stay is secured, such employee is just another Canadian and employer must find another, next one....

    Another aspect is productivity. Canadian workforce is not expensive at all in comparison to developed nations. However, Canadian businesses suffer from lower productivity due to their inability to establish a business model or operational system that would yield higher productivity. If Canadian businesses would properly invest in technology and learning rather than trying to whip their employees, the productivity would be higher and employees more loyal. Unfortunately the reality is all about how

  • It was mentioned last night on MCTV about the shortage of rental units, and it was implied that those that are available, are overpriced. No doubt that has a huge bearing on being able to get people to relocate.

  • While I will agree that if a worker exits school and starts welding at 15 yes by age 28 they will have more experience. Too bad they might so illiterate that they can't do much else, so what happens if they need to do something else? I think keeping our youth in school and educating them properly is important as well.

    Is there a lack of work ethics? YES! Is it in both immigrants and citizens? YES.. but that is a result of how we as a society see life. Everyone acts like they are Donald Trump, no matter what their position in life is!

    I would rather we started training our own population first, mandatory training for social assistance recipients, they refuse good bye benefits. Also local companies have to be more competitive with their wages, welders leaving school in western Canada can get on with a rig crew making way more then $15 an hour to start! Why would someone pass that up? Especially if they are single and have no kids?

  • As said in the article, what scares some people is the move up north. Why not offer to set the person up in an apartment and assist with moving costs? Have them sign a contract for 'x' amount of time so they won't just quit right after moving and things would work out great I imagine.

    FWIW, City Welding quite often advertises on the Canada Job Bank. There is usually a reason for high turnover. Be it low pay, (they start at $15 which is average for a new welder) low morale or bosses that are jerks. Not saying this goes on at City Welding, just it seems odd that they have such a high turnover.

    Unemployment is incredibly high in southern Ontario. Particularly in the Windsor to London and smaller communities that surround the latter. Why not get in contact with a recruitment agency to assist in getting people to relocate?

  • Have you tried Newfoundland or New Brunswick? There are schemes in Newfoundland for people to work off Island for contract work, and there is high unemployment in both those provinces. Maybe low pay and poor working conditions are driving your people away. Foreign workers are more used to a low standard of living and horrible working conditions. When faced with losing a visa and a chance at permanent residency they will put up with a lot of stuff our Canadian workers will not. At minimum wage and no benefits you are better off on welfare. Benefits are the key. In the article it does not say what the pay scale and benefit packages are. Hard to give up dental and drug coverage which is offered to welfare recipients. That being said you will probably attract people over 50 who still have a work ethic. We've bred it out of the younger ones.

  • well Chris, the article does state that recruiting within Ontario and the rest of Canada was tried, but failed. Whats throwing our country into the crapper, is the loss of work ethics. This is why recruiting is done overseas. Once here, the workers get paid the same wage as any canadian would. (gawd, you obviously didnt read the whole story. Perfect example of halfass effort)

  • Why bother getting an unemployed Canadian in another part of the province or country when you can just import an immigrant and pay him peanuts.

    Wonderful. No wonder our country is in the crapper.

  • Sad sign of the times. Pauvre Canada!

  • Exactly. Why work and pay taxes when one can collect social assistance for basically life and work under the table and pay no taxes.

  • A copy of this should be sent to all the school boards as well as the Minister of Education. I put much of the blame on the educational system as time is not of essence to today's educational system. Students can hand in assignments late and not be penalized, they can miss 50% of the classes and still pass and some principals even mandate a 95% pass rate to appease the parents of the children. The whole school system and the socialist point of view has to be completely overhauled. Why work when the bleeding hearts in government and society are prepared to provide subsidized housing, gifts for their offspring at Christmas and free food from the food banks, all from the efforts of others. Yes, there are circumstances where families do need support but it shouldn't be a way of life if one has the mental and physical ability to work.

FacebookTwitterRSSVideophotoNewsletterMobile